Monday, September 15, 2008

A Man Presents a Pseudo-Argument and I Fall Silent

I encountered a man who was completely certain his beliefs were the way every man or woman should abide by, because if they didn’t, they were related to the devil and should be murdered. I met this man in downtown Indianapolis, in the mall-parking garage. I was leaving the garage and paying my ticket when my friend sitting in the passenger side of the car thought it would be a good idea to tell the man sitting in the booth that I was gay as an experiment to see what kind of reaction we would get. The man was appalled. He looked me straight in the eyes and questioned me, asking if this were true, why would I be around a man. Before I could answer he told me that I was wrong and that I should change or God will punish me. His argument and means of support was that the Bible says a man and a woman must lay together. I will never forget when he said, “In my country, Ethiopia, if two women were caught hand in hand they would be killed.” My friend continued questioning, “would you kill a person if they were gay?” This man responded with, “yes, in my country I would, but I can’t here because I would be punished.” I was silent. To this day I am still unsure if I’m ok with my silence. I have been taught to stand up for what I believe in, and I didn’t. Am I a hypocrite? His argument was a pseudo-argument because he was fanatically committed to his position. He was positive he was correct and growth or change was impossible.

1 comment:

Maddie said...

Wow. That's really intense. And to think he would say that to your face is unbelievable. I understand your silence. Sometimes there are moments when we truly don't know what to say or we find ourselves speechless. I've encountered moments like this. The sheer ignorance of people can be astounding and silencing. If you had retorted with a comment, there's no telling how he would have reacted. He might have even yelled at you, or worse.