Tuesday, September 16, 2008

David Langley and Michael Levin

David Langley uses evidence in his piece on skateboarding much like Michael Levin uses evidence in his piece on “A Case for Torture.” In both pieces, they are direct and to the point using short sentence structure. Langley and Levin are addressing different components of life that can be related to fair treatment and the right way to treat others. While Levin is arguing that torture should be used in situations were it is mandatory in order to save innocent lives, Langley argues that skateboarders should be allowed and the people that choose to participate in skateboarding should not be viewed and treated as a criminal. Langley strengthens his argument by referring to his personal experiences in the skateboarding world, where as Levin strengthens his claim by using hypothetical situations to reflect torture as a necessary action to enforce in certain scenarios. Langley and Levin use evidence that is clear, organized, and focused; in order to help support their ideas on two different topics that have to do with the way people should treat others. 

1 comment:

Eryn said...

I think this was a really nice comparison between the two writers. It was nice to have a statement on one that was parallel to a statement about the other. It was easy to see the points you were making with the comparisons.