Overall, I agree with Michael Levin’s argument. If I had the choice then I would not want to torture anyone, but life isn’t always that perfect, there are times when we have to bend or reevaluate our system in order to do what the majority of society believes to be the most ethical. Of course not everyone will agree because everyone has a different idea of what is right and what is wrong. Levin presents several sceneries where an obvious injustice is occurring and he is implying that torture is the only effective way we can impede the injustice. If most humans were asked the question, “is torture bad?” Most would agree it is without thinking. Levin gives us examples of what could happen to make us believe otherwise; to make people believe that in some cases it may be absolutely necessary. This was hard for me to grasp at first, but the more it made sense. There are still parts of Levin’s argument that I think are completely overdone. Some things he said I thought were irrational because he was trying to make his point seem so simple and a point that everyone should agree with. When he says, “If you caught the terrorist, could you sleep nights knowing that millions died because you couldn’t bring yourself to apply the electrodes,” this is not a legitimate or sensible statement at all. However when he says, “if life is so valuable that it must never be taken, the lives of the innocents must be saved even at the price of hurting the one who endangers them,” or, “Americans would be angered to learn that Roosevelt could have had Hitler killed in 1943, thereby shortening the war and saving millions of lives, but refused on moral grounds,” I start to buy into Levin’s argument because he starts to use more reasonable points to support his claim.
Sunday, September 14, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment