Ragged Dick by Horatio Alger is a story that depicts an implicit argument by showing the only way a person can become successful is if they are lucky. Dick is a man that aspires to obtain a position in a store or counting room, instead he is a man that spends half the day blacking boots and is lucky to make three dollars a week. Dick his become accustomed to his position in life and truly believes that he should give up on his goal to become of better stature. Dick, however, happens to be in the right place at the right time. Dick is aboard a boat and has the chance to save a drowning kid and takes it. After rescuing the boy, the father of course feels obligated to reward Dick and offers him a position of clerk in his counting-room making ten dollars a week. Because of his luck with saving a kid and then being presented with a reward, his life was forever changed. “My lucky stars are shinin’ pretty bright now. Jumpin’ into the water pays better than shinin’ boots.” Ragged Dick is ultimately an implicit argument showing that it pays to be lucky and that one must have luck in order to be successful.
Sunday, September 28, 2008
Ragged Dick!
Thursday, September 25, 2008
Visual Arguments!
Technology continues to evolve in our culture and is benefiting society, but is also hindering it in other ways. Because society has become accustomed to the use of technology, it has influenced our learning visually. Studies have been created and results show that humans are beginning to learn better if information is presented to them visually, and this is why a visual argument is a more effective argument.
Writing Arguments makes the claim on page 161 that “visuals can enhance logos, pathos, and ethos of an argument by supporting of clarifying an argument’s logical core, moving audiences imaginatively and emotionally, or enhancing the writer’s credibility and authority.” Even if it feels like one is accessing over minor details when creating a visual argument, one must remember that these details can enhance a visual argument and one must pay close attention to them. Examples of these details include font style and the way in which write the words (bold, caps, italics, etc.) use of color, and design using images and graphics. These are all components that can strengthen one’s visual argument because these details will appeal to one’s audience. A visual argument is more persuasive because today society is shown to have developed a new way of effectively processing information.
Thursday, September 18, 2008
"Ethos" and "Pathos"
When an author is writing any piece and is using “ethos” and “pathos” as a way to help make the writing or argument believable there are certain responsibilities the author holds in order to make “ethos” and “pathos” work. An argument is more persuasive if the audience can trust the speaker (Writing Arguments pg. 131). “In the speaker’s manner and delivery, in the speaker’s tone, word choice, and argument of reasons, in the sympathy with which he or she treats alternative views, the speaker creates a trustworthy persona” (Writing Arguments pg. 131). Aristotle called the impact of the speaker’s credibility the appeal from “ethos.” Writing Arguments suggests three ways a writer can create this credibility; be knowledgeable about your issue, be fair, and build a bridge to your audience (pg. 131). “Pathos” is the ability for a writer to appeal to the reader’s emotions. Writing Arguments focuses on four strategies that writers can use to create appeal from “pathos”; concrete language, specific examples and illustrations, narratives, and connotations of words, metaphors, and analogies (pg. 133). There are times when our media and our government do not live up these ethical expectations. I mostly see the lack of “ethos” and “pathos” in the media more frequently than I do in the government, however the lack of “ethos” and “pathos” still remains in the government. For example, the media lacks “ethos” and “pathos” in the argument for weight loss. I am not able to trust this argument for weight loss because I have known people who have tried different programs and they don’t work. The argument for weight loss lacks “pathos” because often times there is not concrete language, metaphors, or many examples and illustrations.
Tuesday, September 16, 2008
David Langley and Michael Levin
David Langley uses evidence in his piece on skateboarding much like Michael Levin uses evidence in his piece on “A Case for Torture.” In both pieces, they are direct and to the point using short sentence structure. Langley and Levin are addressing different components of life that can be related to fair treatment and the right way to treat others. While Levin is arguing that torture should be used in situations were it is mandatory in order to save innocent lives, Langley argues that skateboarders should be allowed and the people that choose to participate in skateboarding should not be viewed and treated as a criminal. Langley strengthens his argument by referring to his personal experiences in the skateboarding world, where as Levin strengthens his claim by using hypothetical situations to reflect torture as a necessary action to enforce in certain scenarios. Langley and Levin use evidence that is clear, organized, and focused; in order to help support their ideas on two different topics that have to do with the way people should treat others.
Monday, September 15, 2008
A Man Presents a Pseudo-Argument and I Fall Silent
I encountered a man who was completely certain his beliefs were the way every man or woman should abide by, because if they didn’t, they were related to the devil and should be murdered. I met this man in downtown Indianapolis, in the mall-parking garage. I was leaving the garage and paying my ticket when my friend sitting in the passenger side of the car thought it would be a good idea to tell the man sitting in the booth that I was gay as an experiment to see what kind of reaction we would get. The man was appalled. He looked me straight in the eyes and questioned me, asking if this were true, why would I be around a man. Before I could answer he told me that I was wrong and that I should change or God will punish me. His argument and means of support was that the Bible says a man and a woman must lay together. I will never forget when he said, “In my country, Ethiopia, if two women were caught hand in hand they would be killed.” My friend continued questioning, “would you kill a person if they were gay?” This man responded with, “yes, in my country I would, but I can’t here because I would be punished.” I was silent. To this day I am still unsure if I’m ok with my silence. I have been taught to stand up for what I believe in, and I didn’t. Am I a hypocrite? His argument was a pseudo-argument because he was fanatically committed to his position. He was positive he was correct and growth or change was impossible.
Sunday, September 14, 2008
A Case for Torture
Overall, I agree with Michael Levin’s argument. If I had the choice then I would not want to torture anyone, but life isn’t always that perfect, there are times when we have to bend or reevaluate our system in order to do what the majority of society believes to be the most ethical. Of course not everyone will agree because everyone has a different idea of what is right and what is wrong. Levin presents several sceneries where an obvious injustice is occurring and he is implying that torture is the only effective way we can impede the injustice. If most humans were asked the question, “is torture bad?” Most would agree it is without thinking. Levin gives us examples of what could happen to make us believe otherwise; to make people believe that in some cases it may be absolutely necessary. This was hard for me to grasp at first, but the more it made sense. There are still parts of Levin’s argument that I think are completely overdone. Some things he said I thought were irrational because he was trying to make his point seem so simple and a point that everyone should agree with. When he says, “If you caught the terrorist, could you sleep nights knowing that millions died because you couldn’t bring yourself to apply the electrodes,” this is not a legitimate or sensible statement at all. However when he says, “if life is so valuable that it must never be taken, the lives of the innocents must be saved even at the price of hurting the one who endangers them,” or, “Americans would be angered to learn that Roosevelt could have had Hitler killed in 1943, thereby shortening the war and saving millions of lives, but refused on moral grounds,” I start to buy into Levin’s argument because he starts to use more reasonable points to support his claim.
Thursday, September 11, 2008
"Pathos"
“Pathos” is an influential and powerful metaphorical device because “pathos” is what it means to be human. Humans run on emotion; it is what makes us feel important, worthy, and real. Our emotions are only truly felt and have meaning when people are able to connect and understand others’ feelings. Humans must be able to empathize with others’ emotions, humans depend on this connection, and it is intuitive. A connection through “pathos” allows people to identify with what it means and feels to be a person. This is why “pathos” is important in writing. “Pathos engages the imagination and feelings, moving the audience to deeper appreciation of the argument’s significance” (pg. 75, Writing Arguments). Without “pathos” the writing piece and the interpretation of the piece by the reader holds no importance at all. All well developed pieces of writing contain “pathos” because without it the reader can not relate, and if a reader can’t relate then what they are reading is pointless and holds no significance at all.
Sunday, September 7, 2008
Biotech foods
I believe people should only be informed of a biotech product if it differs in any way from the natural product other then the fact that is made differently. We have read claims in earlier pages, for instance the ad on page 24, that make it seem like genetically engineered food could potentially be dangerous to one’s health, the environment, the economy, or the future farming. However, after re-reading the ad one can see that the ad does not have substantial evidence or research to support these claims, and the only reason they say these things is to persuade people to agree that genetically engineered food is a bad thing. However, the argument made on page 41 makes more sense to me. The argument made is, “labeling all biotech foods would make a distinction without a difference. Rather than communicating relevant health or safety information, it would merely explain the process by which the food was developed.” This could ultimately confuse the consumers. I agree with this argument and think it is not necessary to label biotech food.
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
FRANKEN FOODS
The cartoon and the ad are promoting that genetically modified foods are not good for people. The cartoon influences the argument because it is straightforward and simple. The cartoon only supports the argument in a negative way and does not present any counterarguments to show the reader that there are other beliefs about whether genetically modified foods have benefits. We know that the cartoon believes genetically modified foods are bad because there is a starving man in need of food and the man says that he certainly should not eat the corn because it is genetically modified, which shows the man thinks that the beggar would rather starve than eat the genetically modified food. The ad influences the argument because it presents an interesting picture with a relative question that gets the reader to think about what it is the ad is promoting in a different way than just having paragraphs of information. The ad goes beyond the cartoon because not only does it include a simple picture, like the cartoon, but it also has information under the picture to explain what it is that should be done so genetically modified foods can become a lesser problem. I like the question and the picture in the ad because by connecting the fact that not all genetically modified foods are labeled, with the can saying its none of our business to know the nutritional information, is like saying in a creative way our rights to know what we are eating and drinking are not being enforced.
Tuesday, September 2, 2008
Implicit and Explicit Arguments
There are two forms of argument, explicit and implicit. An explicit argument is an ordered structure of particular notion, which provides reasoning and support. “An explicit argument states directly a controversial claim and supports it with reasons and evidence” (Writing Arguments pg. 4). Implicit argument is embedded in items such as pictures or poems and is indirect, but still manages to woo a group of people toward a definite way of thinking. “An implicit argument, in contrast, doesn’t look like an argument. It may be a poem or short story, a photograph or cartoon, a personal essay or an autobiographical narrative” (Writing Arguments pg. 4).
In this introduction to arguments readers are shown two different forms of implicit argument through a Veterans Day photograph and a poem by Wilfred Owen, “Dulce et Decorum Est,” a man who was killed in World War I. The picture implies meaning that to be apart of war is a heroic and respected action. The picture demonstrates that a person who has served should be proud of their sacrifice to our country, while the poem argues that to give up one’s life for one’s country is not a noble action. The poem describes an atrocious moment when a soldier dies because of exposure to a gas attack. Owen ends the poem stating, “The old lie: Dulce et decorum est Pro patria mori.” This means how sweet and fitting it is to die for one’s country, which Owen says is a lie. Owen ultimately entails dying for your country is not gallant in any regard. Both of these examples influences readers with powerful emotions to distinctive ideas of how war should be perceived.