Thursday, December 11, 2008

yeaa progress.

I spent a lot of my time today writing and editing what I have been writing. I find it particularly hard to not state my opinion while attempting to provide my readers with a detailed analysis of my research. I want so much to just let my heated thoughts out and state why I disagree so much with those that find it okay to deny rights of others because it isn't "normal" or "what has always been happening," two statements from a fellow University High School student, however, I know this isn't the assignment. I will simply do my best to present my information in a non-biased way.  

progress at beginning of the week!

I began to organize my information in a way that would help me write my expository draft. It seems I have eliminated a lot of previous information because it doesn't seem to fit with the assignment of the expository draft, which is to explain the issue using the sources as support. However, I did find a germane article that will help me while writing this draft, "The Religious Case for Gay Marriage," by Lisa Miller. 

progress over the weekend

this weekend I spent time gathering information from a number of different groups who support gay marriage and groups that oppose gay marriage. I also focused on understanding each of their reasons for believing what they believe. I found that most of those who opposed gay marriage used reference of the Bible to justify their beliefs. 

Thursday, December 4, 2008

progresssss!!

Today I spent time researching about gay and lesbian rights in Indiana and other states in America. I am sure I want to focus on gay and lesbian rights, I am just not sure if I should focus on their rights in Indiana only, or if I should include other states as well. Also, I was listening to NPR on my way home from school today and heard a controversy held between blacks and gays and lesbians. Some of the African-Americans were saying that they were offended that the gays and lesbians were saying that their fight for their rights is the same as African-Americans fighting for civil rights. I believe that it is the same because we are all people, and although slavery may be a bigger issue, it is still the same; discrimination against a group of people for one of their characteristics. Gays and Lesbians are fighting for justice just like the African-Americans were fighting for their justice in the civil rights movement. An example of a person who did not know which side to agree with was a lesbian who was also African-American. This is interesting because it supports the notion that we are all people wanting to feel liberty and live happily, whether you are white, jewish, handicapped, black, or gay. 

Tuesday, December 2, 2008

more progressss!

I have now decided to focus on either gay rights movement or freedom of the press and have continued tonight to look online for sufficient amounts of information on both topics. I want to find information that is reliable before I decide which topic to choose. I already have my own thoughts and ideas about these proposals, I just need to find good sources. PS. tonight during the game we recited the Pledge of Allegiance and I realized that it is extremely hypocritical. It says, "...liberty and justice for all," and I thought, well that's funny because there isn't liberty and justice for all. So, Susan B. Anthony speaks out for woman's rights, their liberty, and a demand for a change, and things changed eventually. Fredrick Douglas spoke for liberty for slaves and awareness began to promote change and justice for slaves. Martin Luther King Jr. continued in his path and furthered the task for freedom and it happened eventually. My question is, who is speaking for gays and lesbians rights and freedom? When is change going to happen? When will they obtain their freedom? When will our Constitution and Pledge of Allegiance cease hypocrisy?    

Monday, December 1, 2008

I.C. progress!

I have started to research four different topics, freedom of the press, gay rights movement, gays in the military, and year-round schooling. All of these topics interest me because they are controversial and I have strong opinions on each of these subjects. If I focused on homosexuality I am still not sure if I would focus on their rights in Indiana or Nationally. I found an interesting organization for gay rights; National Gay and Lesbian Task Force. 

Monday, November 24, 2008

Let a Thousand Licensed Poppies Bloom

I thought that this essay was effective because it showed the specifics of its proposal by giving a variety of facts for support. The facts that I thought were necessary and germane were that developing countries are home to 80 percent of the world’s population, but they consume just 6 percent of the medical opioids. This shows quite a bit of a contrast, which is an effective way to capture the reader’s attention. The article also says that The United Nations estimated that Afghanistan produced more than 4,200 tons of opium last year and cultivation jumped to 323,701 acres from 197,680 acres in 2003. Because this article presents this information it is effective because it shows the readers that a problem exists and is continuing by giving real numbers as support. This is also being specific, which is also an effective way to present a proposal argument. This essay ends by referencing to the future and the consequences that might happen, this also makes the article efficient. 

Thursday, November 20, 2008

C.P. Ellis

Ellis proposes that in order for people to overcome confusion and hatred between races that causes barriers that are often seen, felt, or even ignored by many, is to engage in dialogue with a race that is not your own and a race that one might not understand. If one attempts to understand a race that one might have prejudices about it is likely that one will move in a direction towards better understanding and learn authentic information from the source of which one is discriminating. Ellis believes that relating to another race in this new, real, way leads to the exchange of personal stories. When one allows themselves to be put in a situation like this, one can discover truth and eliminate some false beliefs one could have and has been a part since raising. No this solution would not work on a large scale. They only possible way it could work is if each person on a micro level contributed by engaging with people of a different race that they might hold prejudices with, if this happened then it would affect everyone on a large scale. This solution would not work on a large scale because not everyone is willing to change their beliefs and are comfortable with their standing and discrimination against another race.  

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

The Pressure to Cover

“The mainstream is a myth” according to Yoshino because no one actually fits into the mainstream people believe and claim our society has, because each individual has to give up, change, or hide aspects of themselves in order to conform to the mainstream to be accepted. However, I believe Yoshino is also saying that each individual varies in the way that they perceive and acknowledge that there is in actuality a “mainstream” that one must accept and hold of virtue because one might have to give up something or change something to become a part of that greater group. Because we all have different perceptions and beliefs as to whether we have a “mainstream” and how it functions and affects our lives, then there ultimately can’t be one because we can’t agree on what it is. I think “mainstream” on a micro level is what an individual finds that they must change or alter to their being in order to fit in at work, home, church, etc. I believe “mainstream” on a macro level to be how society, humanity, or the people function and what implicit or explicit requirements they instill in the communities based on the notions that they have about the rest of society and the beliefs that they think the rest of society has.  The “mainstream” that some might believe may or may not be true, but certain requirements are still instilled due to the notion that they must conserve the peace of society and conformity must happen in order to have happiness for the majority.  

Sunday, November 16, 2008

Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl

Life in the North is still hard for Linda because she is still dealing with the affects of slavery. Linda is scarred with memories. Everyday she will be consumed with thoughts that bring her back to the cruel bondage of slavery. It will seem escaping slavery is inevitable because it will remain alive in her head. Linda realizes that she is still in danger from Dr. Flint’s family, even though she knows Dr. Flint is dead. Linda tries to obtain her freedom when she goes to Mrs. Bruce because she fears that her former mistress will find her. Mrs. Bruce helps her escape and also sends her baby with Linda, and when people come asking for Linda they are told she no longer lives there. Linda ultimately attains her freedom when Mrs. Bruce decides to buy Linda for three hundred dollars. She has mixed feelings about her freedom at the end of the book because she feels like she is not as deserving of Mrs. Bruce’s kindness. It is also hard for Linda because she has lost her grandmother, however she remembers her grandmother and holds on to all that she gave to her as she struggled to survive and obtain freedom.   

Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Lacerated

 

“Was I not already in the dust? But his threat lacerated my heart. I knew the law gave him power to fulfill it…” (page 66). Her rhetoric is powerful and it appeals to my emotions because she is describing a feeling that is real and hard to ever imagine. She is a nonentity and it is hard, sad, and a standing that she believes she can never escape. She is stuck in sadness and realizes she has been degraded to its lowest point. She is nothing more than a piece of dust. She is not accepted by society and this brings the question, does her life mean anything? Is she actually alive if people view her as nothing, a worthless, impassive piece of property? Jacobs uses the word, lacerate; a style choice that makes this quote strong. The word illuminates the condition of her heart. Her heart is wounded, torn, and cut to the core. This enrages me because I understand that the masters provoke these feelings because of their cold, cruel actions and laws. It makes we wonder how could people commit such actions against another human being. How do they convince themselves they are of lesser capabilities and aren’t truly human? 

Sunday, November 9, 2008

Slave Girl

No matter how profane, horrifying, unbelievable, and drastic our history of slavery is, we must be subjected to it in order to try to understand and comprehend just how gruesome and hypocritical these years were. We can begin to comprehend these events best if seen through the eyes that were the recipients of these horrible actions and bondages. It is important to not leave or edit the events of the stories told by the sufferers because we need all prevalent information in order for our established perspectives to be of any accuracy. Although, we may never be able to fully grasp the events of slavery we must try to walk in the paths of these victims and we can only do so by truth. This is why it is important that the book is factual and not fictional. As Americans, citizens of a country that once allowed for the repression of other human beings based on race and the toleration of treating humans as if they were property, degrading people at its lowest means, we must be willing to read and come to a realization of the events that happened not even one hundred and fifty years ago. The only way to reach this knowledge is through authentic writing of events.

OBAMA!

Gathered around the TV with the people I honor, respect, trust, and share the same common beliefs (including political beliefs) on election day was the best way to experience a day that will never be forgotten and will be cherished in my family, as well as the many other families and people gathered at Grant Park in Chicago. It was so uplifting to be surrounded by my group of family friends, a group I have affiliated memories with since I can remember. There were moments of heat, angst, frustration, and amazement as our eyes were glued to the TV and as our mouths reacted and answered the comments and questions of others in the room.
As a sat there watching and listening, my mind began to wonder. I began to think about past elections. Why it is America values elections? What is the importance of elections? How will or nation by changed with the presidency of Obama or McCain? How do people decide which candidate they support? What do they base their reasons on--their parents’ beliefs or their own?
When Obama was elected I can’t describe the feeling that came over my entire body and the atmosphere and joy in the room. I was speechless and almost didn’t believe it. The best way I can describe the feeling; I had pride. We each believed that America had elected a president that would truly try and work for a nation that could be brought back together, when in present time it has felt as if it has been torn a part. I believe in this man and I think we should all accept him as president, despite if one does not agree with his views. We should all at least agree with his morals and his drive to support and change our country for the better.

I Am a Blogger

I assume that I’m only a blogger; however the article in Writing Arguments suggests that I am also a journalist and have the privilege and right to claim the First Amendment ( where I have a “journalist’s privilege” and the right to protect confidential sources) if I am in court and prosecutors need information from me. I qualify as a journalist and can make a claim that I am one, and this is what needs to be adjusted because if it isn’t, then anyone can be protected by the First Amendment. This is what will cause conflict and the ability for people to lose privacy if anyone is allowed to blog and reveal confidential information and get away with it. I agree with Justice Lewis Powell. He suggests ‘journalists should be allowed to claim the privilege, and courts should try to strike “a proper balance between freedom of the press and the obligation of all citizens to give relevant testimony with respect to criminal conduct.”

The Unproductive "N" Word Exchange

Last year in the locker room I was put in a situation where I felt an obligation to say something to one of my African-American friends. She was using the “N” word like it was any other word in the dictionary. It bothered me because I know this word is degrading, strong, and hurtful. I don’t believe a word with so much history should be used in a common conversation because it will lose its power and its true meaning. I told her to stop using the “N” word because it is hurtful and degrading not only to herself but to others. I also told her that it bothered me. She said that it doesn’t hurt her and that she isn’t using it in a degrading way. She also said I couldn’t say anything because I was white, that is her word, and I must not understand. This will confuse me for a long time because I don’t know if what I did was the right thing and if there is any truth in what she was saying. Maybe it wasn’t my place to say anything, maybe she didn’t believe she was using it in a degrading way and that wasn’t her intention, but this is the problem. I don’t believe anybody whether you are white or black should use this word with relaxation; it needs to be used in the right context. This demonstrates that in our society there are words that have lost its impact and meaning (Wachtel expresses this on page 545 in RA). In time people could become immune to this word and this is dangerous. This is an example of how overtime if people are exposed to something or taught something, how easy it is for humans to agree and assume what is being taught or heard is true, when often times what is taught are prejudices and stereotypes. Humans have the ability to become ignorant so easily; and accepting the beliefs of others can be so simple if we aren’t willing to question it and decide for ourselves it is worthy.

Sunday, November 2, 2008

Causes of Prejudice

The socialization process is when individuals gain the beliefs, notions, morals, and insight of their culture or subculture according to Parrillo. He says this includes religion, nationality, and social class. Parrillo believes that children conform to their parent’s ideas and how they perceive the world. A child will adapt to their parents’ way of thinking often times with out questioning if what is being said is wrong; they will automatically assume it is truth. We ultimately learn to prejudices of those we are around most often and they become our beliefs and worth (Parrillo). I do agree that prejudices and beliefs are instilled this way. This is dangerous because if we assume false stereotypes about a particular group it leads to discrimination and intolerance of a particular person because of their color, religion, sexual orientation, etc. And this is morally wrong, but for some people it is inevitable because of the prejudice infused within.  

Thursday, October 30, 2008

Cose

Official investigation, apology, and restitution is important to the victims or descendants of significant historic injustices and discriminations because it shows the people that have suffered or were affected by the injustices that we realize and understand the faults committed against them. We are demonstrating that we see the wrongs and we are creating an obligation to our people to make sure the injustices never happen again. Restitutions are necessary because it allows are people to move forward so we can begin to understand and recognize human beings as fellow Americans and as a whole people instead of distinguishing between each other and make groups that are inferior to another group. As the Declaration of Independence says, “we hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal,” these are the words of our nation and in order to live this notion out we must come to a realization and a thinking that we are all the same people, whether white, black, Asian, or Muslim, and this is what Cose is asking us, how do we get there? Cose proposes that we must acknowledge our nations injustices committed to our people in order to move forward.  He says, “the argument for reparations is essentially an argument about keeping promises and restoring a damaged community, about giving people restitution for what was taken, about providing opportunities that were denied.” 

Thursday, October 23, 2008

Cora Tucker vs. Willy Loman

Cora Tucker and Willy Loman are similar, both people struggle with what it means to be successful in America. They both come from destitute places and work hours upon hours trying to work up to a “better” standing. However, I believe what America as a society believes to be a place of better means can often be just the opposite. The American dream is associated with money; if one has money they are successful. Why is this? Why is everything centered on money? Is it because we are selfish human beings? I become frustrated because money cannot decide the morals and thoughts of the people holding it. I think it is a problem when a person can inherit millions of dollars from a deceased relative and become “successful” without doing or giving anything to society; no return at all. The American dream can be fatal because it can give people false hope. This is where Willy Loman fails; his entire life he held on to a life that was made-up, his life became meaningless. Tucker, however, succeeds; she recognizes America’s terrible system but understands she can’t get away from it fully. She persists in her job and her success is measured with her efforts. Tucker’s efforts and what she has done for her community is substantial, and this is what makes her successful and Willy a failure. 

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Death of a Salesman

Willy believes that every individual has their opportunity; their only obligation is to go out and get it. Support from the play shows that Willy has the same notion American society has always had; if one works extremely hard, then they will earn a high standing in life. We are shown Willy is a believer in the American dream when he says, “The man knew what he wanted and went out and got it! Walked into a jungle, and comes out rich!” Willy has invested his entire life to working and trying to become known as a vital salesman. Throughout the entire play we witness Willy transforming and towards the end of the play, Willy finally has lost all of his energy and burns out. After all of his long hours and years of working we are shown that Willy hasn’t truly been successful and doesn’t make it big.  Willy finally feels as though he has failed in business and with his sons, which ultimately leads to his death.

Arthur Miller believes that individuals have an opportunity, however he isn’t a believer in the American dream, believing anyone can become rich and famous if they try. He shows his beliefs through Biff and Happy. The brothers are opposites, Biff finds joy on a farm and begins to feel he hasn’t gotten anywhere and starts to feel lonely, and in a sense Happy has been successful and is also lonely. Happy says, “it’s what I’ve always wanted. My own apartment, car, and plenty of woman. And still, goddammit, I’m lonely.” Through both of the brothers, Miller is showing that no matter who you are, everyone needs to find balance and a passion. I think Miller is demonstrating that everyone must seek personal truth because that is what is important. What’s not important is conforming to America’s ideal of making it big or one is not successful. Miller is showing us that only individuals can decide what success really means and judge themselves based upon what they decide. 

We Are All Lost

Biff makes a statement at the beginning of this play, and it awaked me; the testimony was what automatically connected me to the characters and forced me to draw parallels between their lives and mine. What I found were many similarities, however different circumstances and a different time period. Biff says, “I tell ya Hap, I don’t know what the future is. I don’t know—what I’m supposed to want."

This is significant because I constantly find myself wondering the same things, and I wouldn’t be surprised if others thought along the same lines.  I believe our world is full of so many distractions while everyone is trying to find and make a living. In America success equals money. Without money it is hard to survive in American society. Biff expresses his passion and joy in raising cattle and when he comes home, he realizes all he has done with his life is waste it. My question for him, if he enjoys it has he wasted his life? Or when he says he has wasted his life, is he comparing his work to his world and that is when he decides he has wasted his life?

If this is the case, then this is the problem; people are always conforming to society in order to be successful. And most people believe if one is not successful in society than existence isn’t worth anything because society looks down upon you. One must not give up their passions because they want to be accepted in society, because the life one would live would be depressing and unfulfilled. I think it is sad to exchange a passion for acceptance from society’s skewed idea of success. People must learn to find happiness within themselves and from their own achievements and stop trying to seek it from the acknowledgement of others.

 Chris McCandless fought with this and ended up dieing. He was tired of society and its many minuscule tribulations. He was tired of seeing people worried about the things in life that  had no importance. Chris thought the only way he could escape it was by leaving it. But he couldn’t leave it. One has to face it, and while facing it, one has to decide on their own how they are going to approach what they see.  Two options: to become a part of society competing for wealth, or to be satisfied with what one earns by doing what makes one happy. 

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Speeches!

I wish I could have seen the presentations today, however, I wasn't there. I am sure Charlie and Aly rocked it though! 

Speeches!

I thought that the presentations were thoroughly prepared and overall I think those that presented did a good job of presenting their organizations in a way that would appeal to logos, pathos, and ethos. Each of us came up with a creative way to grab our attention and I do believe that Mrs. Webster is correct when she said in a presentation it is imperative that the introduction is strong because it is most likely the only thing the audience will remember along with the last thing one says. It is true when I am recalling the performances today I remember my classmates’ opening lines. I remember JP’s opening quotation, "Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime." I thought this was significant because it is relevant to our unit on individual opportunity and connected to his speech. I also remember it because I realized that that quote also conveyed the importance of Heifer international in that Heifer doesn’t just feed for a day it feeds for a long time. I also thought Patrick’s opening was relevant because it is true; I love to shop at Goodwill. I enjoyed listening to my classmates’ speeches!  

Outline Process

Writing the outline for my speech was harder than I thought it would be. I had to consider our time limit, and based on the time had to decide what is important to talk about and what I could leave out. However, I thought every piece of information was vital but I found I could not touch upon it within three minutes. This was the hard part, trying to figure out what is necessary to say in order to get the audience to view Heifer International as an important organization. This is one of my weaknesses in writing; how to be economical with my rhetoric, and this is the challenge I faced when writing my outline. 

I did determine that I should at least include my experience with Heifer International, what Heifer does, Heifer’s history, what it means to “pass on the gift,” and one example of someone who has benefited from Heifer International. Once I established these as my focus for my outline I then tried to organize them accordingly. I thought the outline was an efficient way to prepare for the speech and I hope that I was able to appeal to logo, pathos, and ethos, based on the information I chose to present.  

Why Heifer International

My idea is to do my speech on an organization called Heifer International. I choose this organization not only because I believe it is an organization that should be supported, but also because I have had personal experience with Heifer International and it changed the way I understood my world at thirteen years old. I knew that I had more resources and opportunities than most, and I understood that I was lucky to go to Orchard School and to live in Meridian Kessler. I also knew that there were people in Indianapolis that lived in poverty or on the streets and I knew that for many across the world poverty was what people were accustomed to. Because of Heifer International, I now realize that what I understood, I didn’t actually grasp. I feel that I must do my speech on Heifer International because it is an organization that helps the lives of millions, and the aid is prolonging. Although my classmates will not be able to empathize with what I have learned through Heifer International, I do think they will be able to share compassion with what it feels like to feel obligated to give because of our standing in the world. What I learned through Heifer International is essential to all of us; our source of ultimate meaning is to give and not receive. 

Sunday, September 28, 2008

Ragged Dick!

Ragged Dick by Horatio Alger is a story that depicts an implicit argument by showing the only way a person can become successful is if they are lucky. Dick is a man that aspires to obtain a position in a store or counting room, instead he is a man that spends half the day blacking boots and is lucky to make three dollars a week. Dick his become accustomed to his position in life and truly believes that he should give up on his goal to become of better stature. Dick, however, happens to be in the right place at the right time. Dick is aboard a boat and has the chance to save a drowning kid and takes it. After rescuing the boy, the father of course feels obligated to reward Dick and offers him a position of clerk in his counting-room making ten dollars a week. Because of his luck with saving a kid and then being presented with a reward, his life was forever changed. “My lucky stars are shinin’ pretty bright now. Jumpin’ into the water pays better than shinin’ boots.” Ragged Dick is ultimately an implicit argument showing that it pays to be lucky and that one must have luck in order to be successful.  

Thursday, September 25, 2008

Visual Arguments!

Technology continues to evolve in our culture and is benefiting society, but is also hindering it in other ways. Because society has become accustomed to the use of technology, it has influenced our learning visually. Studies have been created and results show that humans are beginning to learn better if information is presented to them visually, and this is why a visual argument is a more effective argument. 

Writing Arguments makes the claim on page 161 that “visuals can enhance logos, pathos, and ethos of an argument by supporting of clarifying an argument’s logical core, moving audiences imaginatively and emotionally, or enhancing the writer’s credibility and authority.” Even if it feels like one is accessing over minor details when creating a visual argument, one must remember that these details can enhance a visual argument and one must pay close attention to them. Examples of these details include font style and the way in which write the words (bold, caps, italics, etc.) use of color, and design using images and graphics. These are all components that can strengthen one’s visual argument because these details will appeal to one’s audience. A visual argument is more persuasive because today society is shown to have developed a new way of effectively processing information.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

"Ethos" and "Pathos"

When an author is writing any piece and is using “ethos” and “pathos” as a way to help make the writing or argument believable there are certain responsibilities the author holds in order to make “ethos” and “pathos” work.  An argument is more persuasive if the audience can trust the speaker (Writing Arguments pg. 131). “In the speaker’s manner and delivery, in the speaker’s tone, word choice, and argument of reasons, in the sympathy with which he or she treats alternative views, the speaker creates a trustworthy persona” (Writing Arguments pg. 131). Aristotle called the impact of the speaker’s credibility the appeal from “ethos.” Writing Arguments suggests three ways a writer can create this credibility; be knowledgeable about your issue, be fair, and build a bridge to your audience (pg. 131). “Pathos” is the ability for a writer to appeal to the reader’s emotions. Writing Arguments focuses on four strategies that writers can use to create appeal from “pathos”; concrete language, specific examples and illustrations, narratives, and connotations of words, metaphors, and analogies (pg. 133).  There are times when our media and our government do not live up these ethical expectations. I mostly see the lack of “ethos” and “pathos” in the media more frequently than I do in the government, however the lack of “ethos” and “pathos” still remains in the government. For example, the media lacks “ethos” and “pathos” in the argument for weight loss. I am not able to trust this argument for weight loss because I have known people who have tried different programs and they don’t work. The argument for weight loss lacks “pathos” because often times there is not concrete language, metaphors, or many examples and illustrations. 

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

David Langley and Michael Levin

David Langley uses evidence in his piece on skateboarding much like Michael Levin uses evidence in his piece on “A Case for Torture.” In both pieces, they are direct and to the point using short sentence structure. Langley and Levin are addressing different components of life that can be related to fair treatment and the right way to treat others. While Levin is arguing that torture should be used in situations were it is mandatory in order to save innocent lives, Langley argues that skateboarders should be allowed and the people that choose to participate in skateboarding should not be viewed and treated as a criminal. Langley strengthens his argument by referring to his personal experiences in the skateboarding world, where as Levin strengthens his claim by using hypothetical situations to reflect torture as a necessary action to enforce in certain scenarios. Langley and Levin use evidence that is clear, organized, and focused; in order to help support their ideas on two different topics that have to do with the way people should treat others. 

Monday, September 15, 2008

A Man Presents a Pseudo-Argument and I Fall Silent

I encountered a man who was completely certain his beliefs were the way every man or woman should abide by, because if they didn’t, they were related to the devil and should be murdered. I met this man in downtown Indianapolis, in the mall-parking garage. I was leaving the garage and paying my ticket when my friend sitting in the passenger side of the car thought it would be a good idea to tell the man sitting in the booth that I was gay as an experiment to see what kind of reaction we would get. The man was appalled. He looked me straight in the eyes and questioned me, asking if this were true, why would I be around a man. Before I could answer he told me that I was wrong and that I should change or God will punish me. His argument and means of support was that the Bible says a man and a woman must lay together. I will never forget when he said, “In my country, Ethiopia, if two women were caught hand in hand they would be killed.” My friend continued questioning, “would you kill a person if they were gay?” This man responded with, “yes, in my country I would, but I can’t here because I would be punished.” I was silent. To this day I am still unsure if I’m ok with my silence. I have been taught to stand up for what I believe in, and I didn’t. Am I a hypocrite? His argument was a pseudo-argument because he was fanatically committed to his position. He was positive he was correct and growth or change was impossible.

Sunday, September 14, 2008

A Case for Torture

Overall, I agree with Michael Levin’s argument. If I had the choice then I would not want to torture anyone, but life isn’t always that perfect, there are times when we have to bend or reevaluate our system in order to do what the majority of society believes to be the most ethical. Of course not everyone will agree because everyone has a different idea of what is right and what is wrong. Levin presents several sceneries where an obvious injustice is occurring and he is implying that torture is the only effective way we can impede the injustice. If most humans were asked the question, “is torture bad?” Most would agree it is without thinking. Levin gives us examples of what could happen to make us believe otherwise; to make people believe that in some cases it may be absolutely necessary.  This was hard for me to grasp at first, but the more it made sense. There are still parts of Levin’s argument that I think are completely overdone. Some things he said I thought were irrational because he was trying to make his point seem so simple and a point that everyone should agree with. When he says, “If you caught the terrorist, could you sleep nights knowing that millions died because you couldn’t bring yourself to apply the electrodes,” this is not a legitimate or sensible statement at all. However when he says, “if life is so valuable that it must never be taken, the lives of the innocents must be saved even at the price of hurting the one who endangers them,” or, “Americans would be angered to learn that Roosevelt could have had Hitler killed in 1943, thereby shortening the war and saving millions of lives, but refused on moral grounds,” I start to buy into Levin’s argument because he starts to use more reasonable points to support his claim.   

Thursday, September 11, 2008

"Pathos"

“Pathos” is an influential and powerful metaphorical device because “pathos” is what it means to be human. Humans run on emotion; it is what makes us feel important, worthy, and real. Our emotions are only truly felt and have meaning when people are able to connect and understand others’ feelings. Humans must be able to empathize with others’ emotions, humans depend on this connection, and it is intuitive.  A connection through “pathos” allows people to identify with what it means and feels to be a person. This is why “pathos” is important in writing. “Pathos engages the imagination and feelings, moving the audience to deeper appreciation of the argument’s significance” (pg. 75, Writing Arguments). Without “pathos” the writing piece and the interpretation of the piece by the reader holds no importance at all. All well developed pieces of writing contain “pathos” because without it the reader can not relate, and if a reader can’t relate then what they are reading is pointless and holds no significance at all. 

Sunday, September 7, 2008

Biotech foods

I believe people should only be informed of a biotech product if it differs in any way from the natural product other then the fact that is made differently. We have read claims in earlier pages, for instance the ad on page 24, that make it seem like genetically engineered food could potentially be dangerous to one’s health, the environment, the economy, or the future farming. However, after re-reading the ad one can see that the ad does not have substantial evidence or research to support these claims, and the only reason they say these things is to persuade people to agree that genetically engineered food is a bad thing. However, the argument made on page 41 makes more sense to me. The argument made is, “labeling all biotech foods would make a distinction without a difference. Rather than communicating relevant health or safety information, it would merely explain the process by which the food was developed.” This could ultimately confuse the consumers. I agree with this argument and think it is not necessary to label biotech food.  

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

FRANKEN FOODS

The cartoon and the ad are promoting that genetically modified foods are not good for people. The cartoon influences the argument because it is straightforward and simple. The cartoon only supports the argument in a negative way and does not present any counterarguments to show the reader that there are other beliefs about whether genetically modified foods have benefits. We know that the cartoon believes genetically modified foods are bad because there is a starving man in need of food and the man says that he certainly should not eat the corn because it is genetically modified, which shows the man thinks that the beggar would rather starve than eat the genetically modified food. The ad influences the argument because it presents an interesting picture with a relative question that gets the reader to think about what it is the ad is promoting in a different way than just having paragraphs of information. The ad goes beyond the cartoon because not only does it include a simple picture, like the cartoon, but it also has information under the picture to explain what it is that should be done so genetically modified foods can become a lesser problem. I like the question and the picture in the ad because by connecting the fact that not all genetically modified foods are labeled, with the can saying its none of our business to know the nutritional information, is like saying in a creative way our rights to know what we are eating and drinking are not being enforced.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Implicit and Explicit Arguments

There are two forms of argument, explicit and implicit. An explicit argument is an ordered structure of particular notion, which provides reasoning and support. “An explicit argument states directly a controversial claim and supports it with reasons and evidence” (Writing Arguments pg. 4). Implicit argument is embedded in items such as pictures or poems and is indirect, but still manages to woo a group of people toward a definite way of thinking. “An implicit argument, in contrast, doesn’t look like an argument. It may be a poem or short story, a photograph or cartoon, a personal essay or an autobiographical narrative” (Writing Arguments pg. 4). 

In this introduction to arguments readers are shown two different forms of implicit argument through a Veterans Day photograph and a poem by Wilfred Owen, “Dulce et Decorum Est,” a man who was killed in World War I. The picture implies meaning that to be apart of war is a heroic and respected action. The picture demonstrates that a person who has served should be proud of their sacrifice to our country, while the poem argues that to give up one’s life for one’s country is not a noble action. The poem describes an atrocious moment when a soldier dies because of exposure to a gas attack. Owen ends the poem stating, “The old lie: Dulce et decorum est Pro patria mori.” This means how sweet and fitting it is to die for one’s country, which Owen says is a lie. Owen ultimately entails dying for your country is not gallant in any regard. Both of these examples influences readers with powerful emotions to distinctive ideas of how war should be perceived.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Digging with Heather

It was another scorching July morning in Knott, Kentucky. I crawled under the trailer once again with the rest of my crew from youth group. I was preparing for another strenuous day of pounding, scooping of dirt, back pain, laughing, sweating, story telling, Gatorade gulping, and a swarm of puppies laying in the cool piles of dirt that we would create.

Today was the day I was going to begin my third hole of the week, and I was proud, even though I knew the hole would be precisely two feet deep and two feet wide.  Oh, how I dread the twenty-four inch mark on the ruler. No matter how many times I swore the holes got deeper, the measurement would unfailingly announce twenty inches over and over.

Underneath the trailer, were the miscellaneous lost and forgotten wastes. Pipes, toothbrushes, dolls, pieces of chairs, toys, wrappers, spider webs, newspapers, and cartons surrounded the world beneath the unsteady metal tube. But I came to like the atmosphere beneath the trailer. It was like a human that wasn’t self-conscious; it wasn’t ashamed, but only satisfied with its differences. This space was empty, silent, and secluded until we came and decided to create an upheaval. 

We all grabbed our toolboxes, put on our gloves, and began whacking at the dirt at inconsistent speeds with our mini shovels. I kept pounding with all my strength and still the dirt only jumped a little. It was almost as if the dirt was telling me it wanted to be left alone, it was content, and here I was hacking at it in order to help the family that was only about four feet above our heads. I kept banging, and still nothing. This hole was much stiffer than the previous two, and I began to think I was doomed. I laid my body flat against the dirt; maybe a different angle would help. But once my body got there, the coolness of the dirt rose through my t-shirt and I was relaxed. My crew looked over and laughed and said a few things that I didn’t decipher, I was already in a reverie.

I felt a tap on my back; I looked up to see a beautiful blue eyed five year old kneeling before me. It was the girl that lived in the trailer. “Heather! Hey there! What are you up to?”

“Nothin’ just explorin’.”

            Her smile was gorgeous. I sat up and started to dig again.

“Can I Help?”

“Of course.” Her smile widened

She jumped right in with her small hands and she just went. She was determined and dug with a purpose. She looked up at me through her blonde hair, laughed, and continued to dig using every atom that made up her delicate body. She saw me observing her. She stopped for a moment and said, “you need to keep diggin’, you caint just give up, we’re in this together.” Heather was so spirited and had an energy and desire that was contagious. She was happy and proud with what she had, and that is when I decided that Heather, like the atmosphere beneath the trailer, was a human that wasn’t self-conscious, wasn’t ashamed, but only satisfied. She picked up the shovel again and started back up, while I began scooping the dirt away.

 

 

 

=) classs

There is something about Hampl and the way she writes that resonates with me. From her book, I Could Tell You Stories, we have read Red Sky in the Morning and Memory and Imagination; two pieces that I think are well written. Her writing style is clear, eloquent, and captivating. In these pieces she refers to personal memories to make sense of her world and how it works, but I am still able to process her moments and connect them to my own experiences. She creates an idea that if people look at the their surroundings closely and question what they see, they will be able to tie all experiences together, and find a correlation which could lead to truth and understanding not only about oneself, but maybe about others also. Maybe this understanding could lead to a bigger understanding to the question I always think about, why is that that we exist? I think most people wonder what it is that they are here for, what is life and what are we supposed to do with it. Then again it comes back to what Ms. LaMagdeleine said on the first day of class, it is all about individual perspective.  

Monday, August 25, 2008

How to Tame a Wild Tongue

Language evolves because people influence language by the way they choose to communicate with others. Every individual has control over the words they speak in order to converse with others, and because of this freedom language is always evolving. Because language is constantly changing, there are times when language can become a barrier if two humans aren’t able to understand what the other one is saying because they don’t know the language or simply don’t understand the meaning of the words spoken by the other person. Humans use language so they are able to connect and relate to others. Humans have developed language as a system so people are able to portray feelings, thoughts, and beliefs so they can share experiences and stories to give life meaning and importance. As a baby, one has not developed language as a method of communication. Their language is cries; whimpers, sighs, laughs, and their body signals are also used as a way of communication. They are taught words so they can develop a new way of communication in order to adapt to the culture surrounding them. As one grows older, ones language matures and broadens sophisticatedly. There are times when the language one speaks changes according to the people one is conversing with. Usually when a person is talking to a teacher or an adult the language one uses is different then the language used around ones friends. Language is always adjusting so one can communicate on a common level with others in order to reach a general understanding. 

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Red Sky in the Morning

I believe it is the insignificant moments in life that can resonate with a person for a long time and then ultimately become significant. A moment where one beings to realize something about the world around them, or when one understands something more clearly about themselves, and it happens in the strangest ways. These moments can last ten seconds, a minute, or maybe five minutes. The interaction or observation could be bad, good, happy, sad, or exciting. I think a person can never predict when a small moment like this will occur and they certainly can’t force this situation, from what I know it happens naturally and without warning. After time has passed and one continues to think or reference to a specific moment it is then when one understands they have been affected in some way.
I remember when I went to a nursing home to visit my grandmother for the first time. She was in a room with many other residents and they all looked so fragile. Some were sleeping, others eating, and some were talking quietly to themselves. I didn’t know what to think or feel. I do remember feeling a need to talk to the others sitting. I wanted to know who they were too. They looked lost and forgotten and were desperate for love and attention. I tried to remain positive. I asked my grandma what she was thinking about. At that moment her silence was broken. Out of nowhere she lit up. She began to sing with all her strength “Everybody loves me, everybody hates me, I guess I’ll go eat worms, big ones, skinny ones, long ones, fat ones, OH how they do squirm!” I will never forget her voice that sang these words. I don’t know why she sang this or where she learned it, but it will stay with me forever.

Friday, August 22, 2008

WHOOOOT
major struggle