Official investigation, apology, and restitution is important to the victims or descendants of significant historic injustices and discriminations because it shows the people that have suffered or were affected by the injustices that we realize and understand the faults committed against them. We are demonstrating that we see the wrongs and we are creating an obligation to our people to make sure the injustices never happen again. Restitutions are necessary because it allows are people to move forward so we can begin to understand and recognize human beings as fellow Americans and as a whole people instead of distinguishing between each other and make groups that are inferior to another group. As the Declaration of Independence says, “we hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal,” these are the words of our nation and in order to live this notion out we must come to a realization and a thinking that we are all the same people, whether white, black, Asian, or Muslim, and this is what Cose is asking us, how do we get there? Cose proposes that we must acknowledge our nations injustices committed to our people in order to move forward. He says, “the argument for reparations is essentially an argument about keeping promises and restoring a damaged community, about giving people restitution for what was taken, about providing opportunities that were denied.”
Thursday, October 30, 2008
Thursday, October 23, 2008
Cora Tucker vs. Willy Loman
Cora Tucker and Willy Loman are similar, both people struggle with what it means to be successful in America. They both come from destitute places and work hours upon hours trying to work up to a “better” standing. However, I believe what America as a society believes to be a place of better means can often be just the opposite. The American dream is associated with money; if one has money they are successful. Why is this? Why is everything centered on money? Is it because we are selfish human beings? I become frustrated because money cannot decide the morals and thoughts of the people holding it. I think it is a problem when a person can inherit millions of dollars from a deceased relative and become “successful” without doing or giving anything to society; no return at all. The American dream can be fatal because it can give people false hope. This is where Willy Loman fails; his entire life he held on to a life that was made-up, his life became meaningless. Tucker, however, succeeds; she recognizes America’s terrible system but understands she can’t get away from it fully. She persists in her job and her success is measured with her efforts. Tucker’s efforts and what she has done for her community is substantial, and this is what makes her successful and Willy a failure.
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
Death of a Salesman
Willy believes that every individual has their opportunity; their only obligation is to go out and get it. Support from the play shows that Willy has the same notion American society has always had; if one works extremely hard, then they will earn a high standing in life. We are shown Willy is a believer in the American dream when he says, “The man knew what he wanted and went out and got it! Walked into a jungle, and comes out rich!” Willy has invested his entire life to working and trying to become known as a vital salesman. Throughout the entire play we witness Willy transforming and towards the end of the play, Willy finally has lost all of his energy and burns out. After all of his long hours and years of working we are shown that Willy hasn’t truly been successful and doesn’t make it big. Willy finally feels as though he has failed in business and with his sons, which ultimately leads to his death.
Arthur Miller believes that individuals have an opportunity, however he isn’t a believer in the American dream, believing anyone can become rich and famous if they try. He shows his beliefs through Biff and Happy. The brothers are opposites, Biff finds joy on a farm and begins to feel he hasn’t gotten anywhere and starts to feel lonely, and in a sense Happy has been successful and is also lonely. Happy says, “it’s what I’ve always wanted. My own apartment, car, and plenty of woman. And still, goddammit, I’m lonely.” Through both of the brothers, Miller is showing that no matter who you are, everyone needs to find balance and a passion. I think Miller is demonstrating that everyone must seek personal truth because that is what is important. What’s not important is conforming to America’s ideal of making it big or one is not successful. Miller is showing us that only individuals can decide what success really means and judge themselves based upon what they decide.
We Are All Lost
Biff makes a statement at the beginning of this play, and it awaked me; the testimony was what automatically connected me to the characters and forced me to draw parallels between their lives and mine. What I found were many similarities, however different circumstances and a different time period. Biff says, “I tell ya Hap, I don’t know what the future is. I don’t know—what I’m supposed to want."
This is significant because I constantly find myself wondering the same things, and I wouldn’t be surprised if others thought along the same lines. I believe our world is full of so many distractions while everyone is trying to find and make a living. In America success equals money. Without money it is hard to survive in American society. Biff expresses his passion and joy in raising cattle and when he comes home, he realizes all he has done with his life is waste it. My question for him, if he enjoys it has he wasted his life? Or when he says he has wasted his life, is he comparing his work to his world and that is when he decides he has wasted his life?
If this is the case, then this is the problem; people are always conforming to society in order to be successful. And most people believe if one is not successful in society than existence isn’t worth anything because society looks down upon you. One must not give up their passions because they want to be accepted in society, because the life one would live would be depressing and unfulfilled. I think it is sad to exchange a passion for acceptance from society’s skewed idea of success. People must learn to find happiness within themselves and from their own achievements and stop trying to seek it from the acknowledgement of others.
Chris McCandless fought with this and ended up dieing. He was tired of society and its many minuscule tribulations. He was tired of seeing people worried about the things in life that had no importance. Chris thought the only way he could escape it was by leaving it. But he couldn’t leave it. One has to face it, and while facing it, one has to decide on their own how they are going to approach what they see. Two options: to become a part of society competing for wealth, or to be satisfied with what one earns by doing what makes one happy.
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Speeches!
Speeches!
I thought that the presentations were thoroughly prepared and overall I think those that presented did a good job of presenting their organizations in a way that would appeal to logos, pathos, and ethos. Each of us came up with a creative way to grab our attention and I do believe that Mrs. Webster is correct when she said in a presentation it is imperative that the introduction is strong because it is most likely the only thing the audience will remember along with the last thing one says. It is true when I am recalling the performances today I remember my classmates’ opening lines. I remember JP’s opening quotation, "Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime." I thought this was significant because it is relevant to our unit on individual opportunity and connected to his speech. I also remember it because I realized that that quote also conveyed the importance of Heifer international in that Heifer doesn’t just feed for a day it feeds for a long time. I also thought Patrick’s opening was relevant because it is true; I love to shop at Goodwill. I enjoyed listening to my classmates’ speeches!
Outline Process
Writing the outline for my speech was harder than I thought it would be. I had to consider our time limit, and based on the time had to decide what is important to talk about and what I could leave out. However, I thought every piece of information was vital but I found I could not touch upon it within three minutes. This was the hard part, trying to figure out what is necessary to say in order to get the audience to view Heifer International as an important organization. This is one of my weaknesses in writing; how to be economical with my rhetoric, and this is the challenge I faced when writing my outline.
I did determine that I should at least include my experience with Heifer International, what Heifer does, Heifer’s history, what it means to “pass on the gift,” and one example of someone who has benefited from Heifer International. Once I established these as my focus for my outline I then tried to organize them accordingly. I thought the outline was an efficient way to prepare for the speech and I hope that I was able to appeal to logo, pathos, and ethos, based on the information I chose to present.
Why Heifer International
My idea is to do my speech on an organization called Heifer International. I choose this organization not only because I believe it is an organization that should be supported, but also because I have had personal experience with Heifer International and it changed the way I understood my world at thirteen years old. I knew that I had more resources and opportunities than most, and I understood that I was lucky to go to Orchard School and to live in Meridian Kessler. I also knew that there were people in Indianapolis that lived in poverty or on the streets and I knew that for many across the world poverty was what people were accustomed to. Because of Heifer International, I now realize that what I understood, I didn’t actually grasp. I feel that I must do my speech on Heifer International because it is an organization that helps the lives of millions, and the aid is prolonging. Although my classmates will not be able to empathize with what I have learned through Heifer International, I do think they will be able to share compassion with what it feels like to feel obligated to give because of our standing in the world. What I learned through Heifer International is essential to all of us; our source of ultimate meaning is to give and not receive.